Arrhenius Laboratory
Scripps Institution of Oceanography in La Jolla, CA
Home | Research | Members | Recent Publications


LEONIDS - DID THEY MAKE IT TO EARTH?
A. Weigel 1,2 , A. Lepland 2 , S. De 3 , K. Marti 1 , and G. Arrhenius

2 , 1 University of California, San Diego, Department of Chemistry, La Jolla CA 92093-0317, USA, 2 Scripps Institution of Oceanography, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla CA 92093-0236, USA,
3 North Cabin Road, P.O. Baruipur, 24 Parganas, West Bengal 743302, India


In the morning of November 18, 1998, following the spectacular Leonid meteor shower, one of us (SD) found particles spread over the roof terrace in a resi-dence in Baruipur, a suburb of Calcutta, India. Con-sidering time and location, these particles possibly derived from the meteor shower, although the fall was not observed. Other particles collected in connection with the Leonid showers in different parts of India proved to be of terrestrial origin [1].

The Baruipur particles are porous, pale pink to gray, slags of 2-12 mm diameter. Larger particles have irregular shapes whereas smaller ones are often spherical and clustered. No fusion crust is evident on any of the particles. Analyses by SEM-EDS shows heterogeneous distribution of phases with variable proportions of Al, Ba, Si, and Fe and minor abun-dances of S, Ca, K, Ti, Mn, Ni, and Cu. X-ray dif-fraction analyses of powdered samples suggests struc-tures similar to BaFeO3 and BaAl2O4. Metallic iron droplets of 0.1-0.4 mm are present in some particles.

The isotopic abundances of noble gases were stud-ied by stepwise heating in a Ba-rich (L1) and an Al-rich (L5) fragment. Relative to air ratios (Ra) we ob-serve: 4 He/20 Ne~2.1愛a, 20 Ne/40 Ar = 1.1愛a (L1) resp. 4.7愛a (L5), 40 Ar/84 Kr = 1.25愛a (L1) resp. 1.9愛a (L5), and 84 Kr/132 Xe = 1.4愛a. 3 He/4 He in the 300蚓 step of L5 is 12.4愛a and in all other temperature steps of both samples 1.3-2.2愛a. Ne-isotopic ratios of both samples plot close to the mixing line Solar-Air. Ar isotopic ratios differ from air only in the 500蚓 step of L1 ( 40 Ar/36 Ar = 323, 38 Ar/36 Ar = 0.202). Kr-isotopic ratios are atmospheric except 78 Kr/84 Kr <1.1愛a and 80 Kr/84 Kr <2.75愛a. Xe-isotopic ratios m Xe/132 Xe rela-tive to air are plotted in Fig. 1. 124 Xe, 126 Xe, and 128 Xe in the Al-rich sample are strikingly enriched. A plot of 124 Xe/132 Xe vs. 126 Xe/132 Xe ratios of the Al-rich sample define a linear trend (r = 0.999) plotting be-tween tie-lines air-spallation Xe [2] and air-anomalous Xe [3]. In contrast to the anomalous Xe from spallation reactions in SB17 [3], we do not ob-serve any excess 131 Xe. These Xe isotopic excesses are observed in the Al-rich, but not in the Ba-rich phase. Excesses are not consistent with the Ba spallation sig-nature, but trapped Xe has atmospheric signature.

No observed meteorite fall so far has been con-nected to a cometary orbit [e.g., 4]. The non-volatile elemental abundances of comets observed in comet Halley dust and from spectral observations of ablation from cometary dust particles indicate average solar system compositions [5]. The Al-rich and Ba bearing phases of the Baruipur particles and the virtual ab-sence of Mg, and the missing fusion crust are not con-sistent with a cometary origin. For terrestrial sources, this material may represent coal combustion slag, whose precursor phases may have been fine-grained detrital aluminosilicates and biogenic barite that are common mineral impurities in coal. Apparently, the Leonid's haven't made it to Earth - yet.

Acknowledgments:
AW supported by a fellowship from the European Space Agency, AL by NASA grant NAG5-4563.

References:
[1] Bhandari et al. (1999) Current Science, 76, 619.
[2] Marti et al. (1966) Z. Natur-forsch., 21, 398.
[3] Srinivasan (1976) EPSL, 31, 129.
[4] Wetherill (1991) Comets in the Post-Halley Era, 537, Kluwer.
[5] Campins and Swindle (1998) MAPS, 33, 1201.


FIGURES:


Fig. 1


Home | Research | Members | Recent Publications


©Copyright 2002 Arrhenius Laboratory - All Rights Reserved